I have been fairly vocal about the fact that I am not Benefit's biggest mascara fan; there was Benefit Bad Gal Lash which did add volume and length but smudged terribly on me, fast forward a few years and the brand launch Benefit They're Real Mascara. This is arguably one of the most successful mascara's ever and yet I couldn't hop on board - yes it added length to my lashes but it also weighed them down, flaked and generally irritated my eyes. To say I was less than enthused about Benefit Roller Lash Mascara was an understatement. After learning all about the formula, I couldn't have been more wrong, it really is nothing short of wonderful...
As you can see both from the packaging and name of the product, this mascara is based around hair rollers - the wand handle is a nod to retro, pink hair rollers and the spoolie boasts similar technology to Velcro rollers. Benefit Roller Lash Mascara has been created to grip onto the eyelashes, pull them upwards, curl, coat black and set - I guess a little like an eyelash perm, only temporary. The brush head is both curved and on the smaller size (above I have compared all three Benefit Mascara heads for size and style comparison) making it perfect for small eyes. The wand features tiny little hooks which grip onto the smallest eyelashes, somewhat stretching them outwards and upwards, encouraging them to curl - the idea is that you can ditch eyelash curlers. Benefit Roller Lash Mascara also contains an in-built "wand wiper" to ensure that the brush isn't overloaded with product - again to prevent the mascara from overwhelming/weighing down the eyelashes.
Sure the packaging and brush may be novel but does this mascara work? Yes, yes it does! I won't for one moment pretend that it is on par with using separate eyelash curlers but it certainly does open up the eyes. As someone with poker straight eyelashes I was pretty surprised to see a definite uplift and curl, I truly did believe before use that this was just a marketing gimmick. Benefit Roller Lash Mascara has a super lightweight formula so flimsy eyelashes such as my own are not weighed down but it can be applied in layers, should you want a more dramatic look - free from clumps which I personally believe is due to the comb like plastic brush. It is a fairly wet mascara but not really prone to smudging nor flaking, it does leave the eyelashes a little crispy but nothing more than the majority of mascara's out there. It adds length, volume and really opens the eyes but I do not rate it for the bottom lashes, the shape of the brush does not bode well and frankly it just looked odd once applied.
Before and After above
Benefit Roller Lash Mascara in a nutshell? It lengthens, adds volume, separates, won't weigh the eyelashes down, doesn't flake or smudge and really does open the eyes with a slight curling effect for the lashes. As a Benefit mascara-phobe I am more than happy to say this has more than converted me! I forgot to mention above that Benefit Roller Lash Mascara only comes in one shade - Black.
Benefit Roller Lash Mascara will launch on the 1st of March and will retail for
Looks great on your lashes! I always begrudge spending too much on mascara but I might have to give this one a try.
ReplyDeleteZoe xx
http://prettydiamondsolitaire.blogspot.co.uk/
That's PRECISELY what I was thinking.
DeleteI like the sound of the fact it doesn't weigh down lashes as this is what I always have a problem with . Great review. xox
ReplyDeletehttp://www.rainbowsandunicornsblog.co.uk/
Ohh I love how the Mascara Wand has been designed and shaped to resemble Hair Rollers~ ^ 3 ^
ReplyDeleteIt is such a clever and creative idea! ^ ___ ^
www.thedailydollyblog.com
This looks so similar to my favourite mascara but Boots Seventeen!
ReplyDeletewww.britishbeautyaddict.com
this one looks great!♥
ReplyDeletexx
The Stylish Confessions | Fashion & Beauty blog
This mascara sounds amazing! Cannot wait to try it out :)
ReplyDeletehaveyouseenhowshespeaks.blogspot.co.uk
I love that you included before and after pictures as well as a thorough review! :)
ReplyDeletei didn't really like the they're real mascara either, but this one sounds pretty good, i think i'm going to have to grab the march elle issue to get a sample of it! great review x
ReplyDeleteI'm going to try two coats at the weekend, as one made my eyelashes look a bit spidery. Look great on you!
ReplyDeleteI love how you are honest about the They're Real mascara because I totally agree!! I've really really tried to love it, but have found so many other mascaras that perform better.
ReplyDeleteThis is a great review!
xoxo
www.becksbabyy.blogspot.com
I am so getting this! Great review and the before/after results are so clear. Can't wait to try this myself!
ReplyDeleteShireen | Reflection of Sanity
Oooh is this the first time your eyes have appeared in a review? Whatever - as always a fantastic post - can't wait to try this product
ReplyDeleteThis mascara really looks good and the packaing is so cute :) It is such a shame that I only tend to use Waterproof formulations and formulations that are too wet tend to make my lashes droop badly. Benefit does do wonderful products apart from mascaras though~
ReplyDeleteHave a lovely day~ ♥
Ying | * Y i n g c b e a u t y *
X x X x X
I love how slim the wand is - I definitely prefer slimmer wands for a really precise application!
ReplyDeletewww.ceejayell.blogspot.co.uk
Wow they really do look great! I love the packaging of the mascara too!
ReplyDeleteneelamjayna.blogspot.co.uk
I cannot wait until this is featured in Elle magazine, definitely giving this a go x
ReplyDeletepintsizedbeauty.blogspot.co.uk
I can't wait to try it! I am always getting so excited whenever Benefit is launching new products!
ReplyDeleteprettyassummer.blogspot.fr
Wow this looks amazing, I've already pre-ordered Elle when I first heard about it being limited and coming out.
ReplyDeletewww.angerawrs.co.uk
This sounds amazing!
ReplyDeleteStephanie
http://missstephanieusher.blogspot.co.uk/
http://www.bloglovin.com/blog/3436251
xxxx
can't wait to buy and try this!
ReplyDeletelove katy @ THE RAWRDROBE ♡
It looks amazing! I can't wait to try it out :)
ReplyDeletehttp://glassow.com
I used to love They're Real, but I stopped using it for a year or so and when I bought a new tube it irritated my eyes like nothing else - as in I had to buy makeup wipes halfway through the day to get the damn stuff off. I've only heard great things about this though, although for whatever reason Benefit launches just don't excite me.
ReplyDeleteThis look amazing ! After your post i feel that i need it...like so bad ^_^
ReplyDeleteBubblyBeauty
This comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteI'm so excited to try this out, anything that will make my pathetic eyelashes look better is a winner in my eyes
ReplyDeletebabbleswithbeth.blogspot.co.uk
x
I do like benefit's mascaras but have always found their brushes too big. This one looks more of a normal size so I may get on better with it. Don't think I could ever ditch my curlers though!
ReplyDeleteBeating Around the Blush
loooks great on you!
ReplyDeletethis is the first actual review i've seen of the product but the packaging is flawless (as usual, benefit) and the applicator looks awesome!
ReplyDeleteNatalie / Salt & Sail
I do really like the concept of this - mascaras are so personal but I'm willing to give it a go and see! xx
ReplyDeleteMagpie Jasmine || Palette Giveaway: Urban Decay, Nars, Charlotte Tilbury, Too Faced
It looks so promising but the wand looks IDENTICAL to the new Maybelline Lash Sensational mascara in the metallic pink tube? I don't suppose you have it to do a dupe post? :D xxx
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing, this is the first review I have seen on this mascara! So excited to try!!
ReplyDeletexoxo Nicole
http://www.brazenbrunette.com
I havent seen this mascara anywhere yet! Looks great and I wasn't a They're Real! fan either! I just can't justify the money for an average mascara!
ReplyDeletehannah @ http://hansaddiction.blogspot.co.uk/
I love They're Real and this appears to be similar so I'm anxious to try it out. It looks great on you!
ReplyDeleteFollow me to Fancieland!
I love the They're Real mascara too, this one really does live up to Benefits great mascara expectations www.shehearts.net
DeleteI love the Benefit They're Real, I am definitely going to try this mascara.
ReplyDeletehttp://milkshakekingdom.com/
Have just preordered Elle! Cannot wait to try this, if it doesn't work for me, I'll still have a good magazine to read... Bean's Beauty Blog
ReplyDeletecan't see the RRP... but if you are impressed I am hopeful
ReplyDeleteLove this mascara, just bought the Elle and blogged about it as well
ReplyDeleteDanielle Mac
im not keen on theyre real liner or mascara, they just smudge and flake so it will be good to test this one. theres a free one with Elle magazine, just out
ReplyDeleteLove the effect!
ReplyDeletebreathefashion-world.blogspot.co.uk
I'm a fan of this mascara! Also review this recently :) How do you compare it to the They're Real mascara? www.shehearts.net
ReplyDeleteI love Benefit and I love their mascara. I'm wondering...have you or any of your readers been introduced to Younique's Moodstruck 3D fibers mascara? You can find it here: www.youniqueproducts.com/wboozer. I'd love to help you with any questions or a purchase. :)
ReplyDeleteI love They're real mascara and this one is even better in my opinion. Benefit doesnt dissapoint in their mascaras. Round of applouse lol
ReplyDeleteI am exactly the same! I didn't like either of the past Benefit Mascara's but this one I fell completely in love with. It keeps my lashes in the curled position all day which is a first, considering all other mascara's I have tried never mastered this! I love it.
ReplyDeletehttp://lucierebekahh.blogspot.co.uk/ x
I love the shape of the brush especially for bottom lashes. But it's not worth the money at all in my opinion! and I found a drugstore dupe thats so much better: Maybelline Lash Sensational. You can see the comparison here:
ReplyDeletehttp://www.classicallycontempo... X